Skip to content
Home » HR Industry Articles » Mastering Interviewing Techniques for Employers

Mastering Interviewing Techniques for Employers

    Hiring the right employees is critical for the success of any business. The interview process plays a pivotal role in this endeavor. Employers must follow proper interviewing techniques to ensure they make informed and legal hiring decisions. In this article, we will explore the best practices for interviewing prospective candidates and the legal considerations that employers must be aware of.

    The Importance of Effective Interviews

    Effective interviews are a fundamental aspect of the hiring process. They help employers identify the most suitable candidates, reduce turnover, and enhance workplace productivity. By conducting interviews efficiently and professionally, employers can make more informed hiring decisions.

    Preparing for the Interview

    Before the interview process begins, employers should undertake several crucial steps to ensure the process goes smoothly and is productive.

    1. Define the Job Requirements: Clearly define the job role and its responsibilities. This will serve as the basis for drafting the job description and interview questions.
    2. Create a Structured Interview Plan: Develop a comprehensive interview plan that outlines the process, the questions to be asked, and the evaluation criteria.
    3. Select the Interview Panel: Choose a team of interviewers who will evaluate the candidate. Ensure that they are well-versed in the job requirements and interview techniques.
    4. Review Resumes and Applications: Thoroughly review the candidate’s resume and application to understand their background and qualifications.

    During the Interview

    The interview itself is a critical stage, and employers should be mindful of their approach, questions, and the candidate’s experience.

    1. Establish a Comfortable Environment: Create a welcoming and professional atmosphere for the interview. Start by introducing the panel and explaining the interview process.
    2. Ask Open-Ended Questions: Craft open-ended questions that encourage candidates to provide detailed responses. For example, ask, “Can you describe a situation where you faced a challenging task at your previous job and how you resolved it?”
    3. Use Behavioral Interviewing: Behavioral questions ask candidates to recount past experiences and actions, giving insights into their capabilities and problem-solving skills.
    4. Active Listening: Pay close attention to the candidate’s responses. Show that you value their input by nodding, maintaining eye contact, and asking follow-up questions.

    After the Interview

    After the interview, it’s essential to follow through with appropriate post-interview actions and decisions.

    1. Evaluate the Responses: The interview panel should meet to discuss the candidate’s responses and compare them against the established evaluation criteria.
    2. Check References: Contact the candidate’s references to verify their qualifications and background.
    3. Provide Feedback: After making a decision, inform the candidates about the outcome, whether it’s a job offer or rejection. Be constructive and professional in your feedback.

    Legal Considerations in Interviews

    Employers must conduct interviews in compliance with labor laws to avoid potential legal issues. Here are some critical legal considerations for employers:

    Equal Employment Opportunity (EEO)

    1. Avoid Discrimination: Under EEO laws, it’s crucial to ensure there’s no discrimination in the hiring process based on factors such as race, gender, age, religion, disability, or national origin. Create interview questions that are fair and unbiased.
    2. Reasonable Accommodation: If a candidate has a disability and requests reasonable accommodations for the interview, employers must comply with this request as required by the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA).
    3. Preventing Retaliation: Employers should refrain from any retaliatory actions against candidates who assert their rights under EEO laws.

    Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA)

    1. Exempt vs. Non-Exempt Status: Ensure that candidates are properly classified as either exempt or non-exempt employees based on the FLSA guidelines. This affects wage and hour laws, including overtime pay.
    2. Compensation Discussions: When discussing compensation during the interview, be sure to comply with FLSA requirements. Wage discussions should be in accordance with minimum wage and overtime laws.

    Immigration and Reform Control Act (IRCA)

    1. Employment Verification: Verify the employment eligibility of candidates through the I-9 form as required by the IRCA. However, it is crucial not to discriminate based on national origin or citizenship status.

    Privacy and Background Checks

    1. Background Checks: When conducting background checks on candidates, adhere to the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA). Obtain written consent from the candidate before performing any checks, and inform them of their rights if adverse action is taken based on the results.
    2. Protecting Candidate Data: Safeguard the personal information and data collected during the interview process to comply with data privacy laws, including the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) if applicable.

    Common Interviewing Mistakes to Avoid

    To conduct effective interviews, employers must also be aware of common mistakes that can hinder the process and potentially lead to legal issues.

    Inadequate Preparation

    1. Lack of Interviewer Training: Failing to provide proper training to interviewers can result in unstructured interviews, leading to inconsistent evaluations.
    2. Unfocused Questions: Asking generic or irrelevant questions can prevent interviewers from obtaining the information they need to make informed decisions.

    Biased Decision-Making

    1. Unconscious Bias: Interviewers should undergo training to recognize and mitigate unconscious bias that may affect candidate evaluations.
    2. Rushing Decisions: Making hasty hiring decisions without thoroughly evaluating candidates can lead to missed opportunities to hire the best fit for the position.

    Inconsistent Communication

    1. Inadequate Feedback: Failing to provide candidates with constructive feedback after the interview can leave a negative impression.
    2. Lack of Follow-Up: Not following up with references or conducting thorough background checks can lead to hiring unqualified candidates.


    Mastering proper interviewing techniques is essential for employers seeking to make informed, legal, and successful hiring decisions. By preparing effectively, adhering to legal guidelines, and avoiding common interviewing mistakes, employers can build a strong and productive workforce that contributes to their organization’s success. Employers should continue to stay updated with the latest legal requirements and industry best practices to refine their interviewing techniques continually.

    Note: Information found on this site is information only and is not intended to be used as legal advice. Please consult your attorney or counsel for specific legal information.